Selling on

For the past eight months or so, I’ve managed an Amazon Seller account for my summer job at a small camera shop business, and I thought I would share some common misconceptions, observations,  and my projections of what E-Commerce will look like in the future.


One of the most common misconceptions people have about is that Amazon sells everything on the site. I’ve dealt with countless customers who call our physical retail store because Amazon provides our phone number for customer service of products we ship to customers, and people genuinely believe we’re and proceed to tell us about their previous purchases (like how much their cat likes the cat food they bought from “us” two weeks ago, etc.). does sell a considerable array of products, but over 40% of their sales are from third-party sellers.

Amazon has put small online retail websites out of business. This is sometimes true, but it depends on the product. Amazon has become the #1 online retail store for one reason, the long-tail. Amazon’s philosophy is that your typical retail store can carry only a certain number of products with a considerable demand, and it’s not economical to carry products that sell 20 or so times a year. However, when your buying population is no longer confined to a small geographic area, it becomes profitable to carry very low demand products because a low demand is enough when spread across the entire country. cannot currently carry the full long-tail of every category of products, but third-party sellers can, which is why small niche businesses like the camera shop I work at are enormously successful on Amazon. This is a win-win for Amazon because Amazon receives commission from our sales, people know they can find this product on Amazon, and Amazon has a full snapshot of the buying market. So, if Amazon sees a product they aren’t currently carrying is tremendously popular, they can decide to carry the product and make the whole profit instead of just the commission.


The relationship between eBay and Amazon reminds me of the relationship between Myspace and Facebook. Both eBay and Amazon have the same function, you sell stuff on their site, but on eBay you have almost complete control of the presentation of your product (do you want a picture? do you want four? how do you want your listing to display in search results? you can structure your own description using HTML, and each listing looks almost completely different). Amazon, on the other hand, has a rigid structure and the locations of information for every product is exactly the same (sellers have no control over the organization of the product page). Myspace allows the user to write the HTML to present their page while Facebook is rigidly structured (you fill in the required fields, and shazam you’re done). While I feel that eBay has niche in its used product market, I don’t think eBay will ever grow into the online super-retailer that Amazon has become.

Amazon has to be the lowest priced listing for a product–even if that means selling it below cost. Amazon makes enough money from its other services and from its third-party sellers to make up for this apparently. For example, their Amazon Kindle is sold for $50 below cost (and is even on sale for below its retail price currently).


Although right now, Amazon is helping many small niche retailers, eventually (in the distant future) I believe Amazon will control the entire online market. Currently, Amazon typically takes about six months to realize that a product is extremely popular before they stock it, but there are very few products that have been listed for more than six months that Amazon isn’t a seller on. So, usually, we can make a lot of money on the product after it is released until Amazon becomes a seller and undercuts our price. Luckily, camera technology evolves so quickly that products phase in and out within two years, so we have plenty of opportunity to sell products as soon as they released. Also, camera and camera equipment manufacturers ship us new inventory before other retailers because we’re a small business, and they like to keep small business alive. But, ultimately, I believe Amazon will begin to pre-list products before they’ve come out and capture all pre-orders/be able to accurately predict the demand for a product and always have enough inventory to satisfy demand all while maintaining the lowest price. The amount of information they capture is simply amazing to me.

Feel free to ask me any questions if you them.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Selling on

  1. jayraina says:

    The most interesting point you brought up was the comparison between Facebook/Myspace and Amazon/eBay. I can definitely see the advantages of keeping structure to website – profiles are standardized so you know what to expect and you know where to look. However, I couldn’t think of too many advantages for unstructured websites other than they offer users to have the leisure of being able to add their own elements.
    Why did MySpace and eBay give users that freedom, while Facebook and Amazon didn’t?
    What are the benefits/costs of having these two different structure in your opinion?

    • dkoleanb says:

      Myspace and eBay may have given users that freedom because it shifts the onus of “filling in the blanks” from the site to the user, and the site is viewed less accountable for the information that it contains (ie: if a seller breaks MAP [Minimum Advertised Price] or if there’s some scandal on Myspace), the accountability falls on the user rather than the site itself because the site can say “I had no idea–I have such loose policies that I cannot be held responsible.” Other than that, the sites with less structure are a huge appeal for some users who prefer to have more control over their profile/listing. In addition, I imagine consumers who want to sell things online may view eBay as more approachable than Amazon, but I’m not sure how I would discuss this in terms of Myspace.

  2. aserafim says:

    Amazon’s prices is whats keeping them on top. That’s why business like Borders are failing because you can buy the book for half the price on Amazon. Amazon doesn’t have brick-and-mortar stores, so it doesn’t have those costs that other businesses have, which allows them to sell their products for cheaper. Plus, the super saving shipping on orders over $25 allows Amazon to get you to spend more money to get the free shipping. But, there are some deals that other retailers have that Amazon cannot provide, or doesn’t have the cheapest prices. I believe Amazon will be the king of online retail, but I don’t think they will control it, since there are others in certain markets (Asia) that have their own kings.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s